The light brown dye seemed to transfer a bit onto a white shirt after wearing it. This missed the mark for me on multiple fronts.

The light brown dye seemed to transfer a bit onto a white shirt after wearing it. This missed the mark for me on multiple fronts.

It arrived well packaged and in perfect condition. Overall I'm really happy with this vest, would buy again.

It arrived well packaged and in perfect condition. Overall I'm really happy with this vest, would buy again.

Overall a solid vest, just a couple of minor nitpicks keep it from a perfect score. Shipping was quicker than I expected. I was impressed by how solid the cotton feels once it arrived.

Overall a solid vest, just a couple of minor nitpicks keep it from a perfect score. Shipping was quicker than I expected. I was impressed by how solid the cotton feels once it arrived.

The cotton is fine, nothing special but does the job. It has two on the waist and two inside, which is standard but useful. Mixed feelings on this one, some things I like, some I don't. Just got this vest and here are my thoughts. Fits true to size, I'd recommend ordering your normal size.

The cotton is fine, nothing special but does the job. It has two on the waist and two inside, which is standard but useful. Mixed feelings on this one, some things I like, some I don't. Just got this vest and here are my thoughts. Fits true to size, I'd recommend ordering your normal size.

It looks decent, about what I expected from the listing photos. The stitching is fine, not the neatest I've seen but functional. I picked this up for my mother-in-law and they've been wearing it a lot. Shipping took a little longer than expected but arrived fine. A zipper closure feels a bit flimsy and catches sometimes.

It looks decent, about what I expected from the listing photos. The stitching is fine, not the neatest I've seen but functional. I picked this up for my mother-in-law and they've been wearing it a lot. Shipping took a little longer than expected but arrived fine. A zipper closure feels a bit flimsy and catches sometimes.

I was let down by how the cotton feels, a bit flimsy honestly. Average experience overall, might work better for someone else. A zipper closure works fine, though it's a little stiff at first.

I was let down by how the cotton feels, a bit flimsy honestly. Average experience overall, might work better for someone else. A zipper closure works fine, though it's a little stiff at first.

A soft viscose lining makes it comfortable to wear over a t-shirt. I like that it has a zipper closure, it's easy to use one-handed. Couldn't be happier with this purchase, five stars from me.

A soft viscose lining makes it comfortable to wear over a t-shirt. I like that it has a zipper closure, it's easy to use one-handed. Couldn't be happier with this purchase, five stars from me.

A neckline style collar adds a nice detail and sits well. Really good purchase, would still recommend despite a small gripe or two.

A neckline style collar adds a nice detail and sits well. Really good purchase, would still recommend despite a small gripe or two.

The cotton held up fine through a few weeks of regular wear. I sized up to 3XL and now it fits perfectly over a sweater. No complaints at all, this is exactly what I wanted.

The cotton held up fine through a few weeks of regular wear. I sized up to 3XL and now it fits perfectly over a sweater. No complaints at all, this is exactly what I wanted.

Wouldn't recommend unless the issues I mentioned don't bother you. A neckline style collar is fine, keeps its shape reasonably well. Had some trouble with a zipper closure snagging early on.

Wouldn't recommend unless the issues I mentioned don't bother you. A neckline style collar is fine, keeps its shape reasonably well. Had some trouble with a zipper closure snagging early on.

Construction is average, a couple of loose threads but nothing major. Good vest for the price, not perfect but close.

Construction is average, a couple of loose threads but nothing major. Good vest for the price, not perfect but close.

Packaging was simple but the vest arrived undamaged.

Packaging was simple but the vest arrived undamaged.

Been wearing this for a few weeks now. No complaints at all, this is exactly what I wanted. A neckline style collar looks sharp and holds its shape. I ordered my usual size L and it fit true to size.

Been wearing this for a few weeks now. No complaints at all, this is exactly what I wanted. A neckline style collar looks sharp and holds its shape. I ordered my usual size L and it fit true to size.

It looks decent, about what I expected from the listing photos. The fit is decent, slightly loose in the shoulders on my XL.

It looks decent, about what I expected from the listing photos. The fit is decent, slightly loose in the shoulders on my XL.

Couldn't be happier with this purchase, five stars from me. Great fit overall, the sleeves land right at my wrist. Picked this up last month and wanted to leave a review. The stitching is clean and even all the way around. A neckline style collar adds a nice detail and sits well.

Couldn't be happier with this purchase, five stars from me. Great fit overall, the sleeves land right at my wrist. Picked this up last month and wanted to leave a review. The stitching is clean and even all the way around. A neckline style collar adds a nice detail and sits well.

Sizing seems inconsistent, my usual size didn't fit as expected. Not what I was hoping for, probably won't order again.

Sizing seems inconsistent, my usual size didn't fit as expected. Not what I was hoping for, probably won't order again.